Exploring the Sweet and Sour Side of "Isla and the Happily Ever After" by Stephanie Perkins
As a long-time fan of Stephanie Perkins, I was eagerly counting down the days until the release of "Isla and the Happily Ever After." After adoring "Anna and the French Kiss" and wrestling with my mixed feelings about "Lola and the Boy Next Door," I had high hopes for Isla’s tale. The prospect of diving back into the vibrant, romantic atmosphere of Paris was tantalizing. But alas, my dear readers, this journey left me a little heartbroken.
Characterization Conundrums
The crux of my disappointment lies squarely with Isla. While Anna’s relatable quirkiness and Lola’s bold individuality had charm, Isla felt like a shadow. We’re introduced to a character who is described more than she is shown. Isla’s supposed love for high heels and her artistic flair remain superficial, leaving her identity as elusive as a fleeting Parisian sunset. Instead of a well-rounded character, she often felt like a cardboard cutout—a Bella Swan 2.0, whose entire life revolves around Josh, with precious little else to define her.
Josh, on the other hand, had moments of brilliance. His artistic sensibilities and moments of vulnerability were delightful and hinted at Perkins’ signature charm. Yet, their relationship dynamics raised my eyebrows more than once. The unusual closeness with her brother, Kurt, sparked confusion. Isla’s insistence on sleeping in the same bed without clear boundaries didn’t sit well with me. I found myself questioning not just the nature of familial love, but also how Perkins portrayed such relationships. It felt awkward rather than endearing.
Pacing and Plot Problems
In terms of pacing, I felt the story dragged at times. The plot was slow to unfold, relying on repetitive ‘will they or won’t they’ tropes that ultimately felt juvenile. The rapid-fire romance that escalated to “I love you” within days seemed unrealistic, even for high school dating. I couldn’t help but roll my eyes at the teenage melodrama—so many feelings but so little substance.
A glaring hole in the narrative was the believability of their escapades, particularly concerning finances— were they funding their trips on fairy dust? Would a rich teen like Josh really rely solely on his mom’s rules? These little inconsistencies chipped away at my suspension of disbelief.
Writing Style and Memorable Moments
While Perkins’ prose is often lyrical, some moments felt overly dramatic and artificial. A snippet like, “I want him closer. I want him deeper. I want him, want him, want him,” read more like a high school poetry assignment than a genuine expression of intimacy. It detracted from the emotional weight the scenes could have carried.
Yet, some memorable quotes shone through, capturing fleeting moments of vulnerability that reminded me of why I fell for Perkins in the first place. The acknowledgment of love as both exhilarating and burdensome was a poignant high point that ultimately left me yearning for a more developed exploration of these themes.
Final Thoughts
Despite my criticisms, I remain grateful for the journey through Paris with Isla and Josh. It’s difficult to reconcile the anticipation I held with the end product. Maybe if you’re a fan of sweet yet tumultuous romances, you might find something here to enjoy. However, anyone seeking depth and rich character growth might want to steer clear.
Still, I can’t help but cheer for Perkins—her dedication to her craft and openness about her struggles are admirable qualities that resonate deeply with me. She may have missed the mark with Isla, but there’s always hope for her next adventure in the literary world. For dedicated fans, it’s a must-read simply to complete the journey, even if it ends with a little more sour than sweet. ✨
Discover more about Isla and the Happily Ever After (Anna and the French Ki… on GoodReads >>
