Book Review: Messy Perfect by Tanya Boteju
As a book blogger, there’s this special thrill that comes from diving into a new release, especially one from an author I already admire. Tanya Boteju has a knack for creating characters and stories that linger in your mind long after you’ve closed the book. With her latest novel, Messy Perfect, I felt that familiar spark of excitement mixed with curiosity—especially knowing it touches on themes of faith and identity. Being raised in a religious environment myself, I was eager to see how Boteju would navigate these complex waters.
Messy Perfect introduces us to Cassie Perera, the quintessential overachiever at her Catholic high school. She’s acing her classes, securing spots on various sports teams, and volunteering like it’s her second job. But when her childhood friend Ben re-emerges, everything shifts for Cassie. Their past is heavy with guilt, and in an attempt to reconnect and make amends, Cassie starts an underground Gay-Straight Alliance (GSA). This act of rebellion not only changes her life but also opens up a community she never knew she needed.
From the get-go, Cassie resonated with me. Her relentless drive was both admirable and concerning—I often found myself thinking, “Girl, don’t burn out!” The portrayal of her character is so well done that I felt her emotional struggles, particularly around navigating her identity in relation to her upbringing. Ben was a great supporting character as well, and I was genuinely amused by his plot twists, adding delightful layers to the narrative.
One aspect that truly sets this book apart is its nuanced exploration of faith. Boteju doesn’t shy away from representing a spectrum of beliefs. Some characters are ready to toss aside their religious roots, while others grapple with how to reconcile their faith with their identities. This multifaceted portrayal is refreshing and handled with grace, making it relatable for anyone with similar experiences.
However, I did find a couple of elements less believable. The idea that a Catholic high school wouldn’t have security cameras monitoring public areas like hallways seemed a stretch, especially in 2024. Such inconsistencies can pull a reader out of the story, but thankfully, they didn’t overshadow the emotional core of the narrative. Additionally, while I appreciated the broad representation of queer identities, I noted the absence of trans feminine characters, which stood out to me. I hope this was an oversight rather than an omission, as inclusion matters tremendously in contemporary literature.
Overall, Messy Perfect is an engaging and heartfelt read. It dives deep into themes of identity, friendship, and the courage to be oneself—all while resonating with those who have experienced the complexities of growing up in a religious environment. I wholeheartedly recommend this book to young adults and anyone looking for a poignant exploration of bravery and self-discovery. It’s a story that not only entertains but also sparks important conversations about faith and identity.
Thank you, HarperCollins, for providing me with this ARC. I can’t wait to hear your thoughts on this one! 🌟
Discover more about Messy Perfect on GoodReads >>