Exploring Dreams and Realities: A Review of Out of My Dreams by Sharon M. Draper
There’s something undeniably magnetic about Out of My Dreams, the latest installment in Sharon M. Draper’s Out of My Mind series. As a fan of middle-grade fiction that tackles profound themes with sensitivity and insight, I was excited to see how Draper would continue Melody’s story in this 2024 release. Melody is familiar to many of us—a 12-year-old girl with cerebral palsy who communicates through a motorized wheelchair and an electronic nonverbal communication board. Her journey has resonated deeply with readers, and I couldn’t wait to dive back into her world.
In this third book, we follow Melody on a journey to London, a setting that initially sparks a sense of adventure and possibility. However, as I turned the pages, I sensed the story beginning to lose its way. Draper introduces a wealth of elements—friends, family dynamics, and cultural references that resonate with the reader, but the narrative often devolves into a series of unconnected events that fail to progress the plot meaningfully. The themes of perseverance and friendship are present, yet they feel overshadowed by a lack of direction.
While the opening chapters are filled with intrigue, showcasing Melody’s aspirations and her unique perspective on the world, by the time I reached Chapter 28, I found myself asking, “What are we truly exploring here?” The captivating idea of a grand journey soon felt like a collection of disjointed scenes. This sentiment was echoed in my annotations—what started strong slowly turned into a sense of filler as several promising storylines fizzled out without satisfying resolutions.
Draper’s writing style, as always, is accessible and vibrant, which makes it easy for young readers to connect with Melody’s experiences. The incorporation of pop culture references—from Beyoncé to Shakespeare—adds a rich layer of relatability for kids and adults alike, but it also contributes to the wandering nature of the narrative. Some moments spark joy, like the nostalgic references to famous literature that I hold dear, yet they sometimes distract from the overall coherence of the story.
One of my favorite aspects of the book was its exploration of media and social dynamics, particularly how they influence Melody’s world. There’s a compelling discussion on the impact of celebrity culture and social media—an element that can foster connection yet also complicates friendships. Unfortunately, as Melody navigates these complexities, the plot struggles to keep pace with her journey, leading to a somewhat unsatisfactory conclusion.
While I wanted to wholeheartedly recommend Out of My Dreams, I find myself unable to do so. There’s merit in the journey and valuable lessons that can be gleaned for young readers, but they might benefit more from the earlier books in the series, which offer a clearer vision and deeper engagement with Melody’s inspiring story.
In conclusion, if you or a young reader is seeking a lovely character in Melody, Out of My Heart or Out of My Mind would be the wisest choices. This latest adventure in London might have its fleeting moments of magic, but it ultimately left me longing for the richness of their predecessors. It’s a reminder that sometimes, the most beautiful journeys are not defined solely by destinations but by the paths we take and the connections we foster along the way.
Discover more about Out of My Dreams (Out of My Mind #3) on GoodReads >>