Book Review: Out of My Heart (Out of My Mind #2) by Sharon M. Draper
As someone who shares the experience of a physical disability, Sharon M. Draper’s Out of My Heart initially intrigued me. I had fond memories of reading Out of My Mind in high school, a book that, despite its flaws, resonated with me in a way that made me feel seen. When I accidentally picked up the sequel, I hoped for a continuation of that connection. However, what unfolded instead was a disappointing narrative that left me feeling frustrated and disheartened.
Key Themes and Characters
Out of My Heart follows Melody as she embarks on a summer camp adventure designed for kids with disabilities. While the premise had potential for empowerment and inclusivity, the execution was riddled with ableist tropes that I found deeply troubling. Melody’s character sometimes felt like a vehicle for clichés rather than a fully realized individual. For instance, her frequent comparisons between her abilities and those of her able-bodied peers perpetuated a narrative that seems to suggest disability is synonymous with limitation—a message that can be harmful to young readers navigating their own identities.
Draper attempts to engage with themes of friendship and resilience, yet the book falters under the weight of stereotypes and awkward portrayals. One moment, for example, sees Melody being told to “shut down the pity party” around her disability. Really? This mischaracterization of emotions reinforces damaging stereotypes that many of us are fighting against daily.
Writing Style and Pacing
In terms of writing style, Draper’s prose is straightforward, likely to appeal to younger readers. However, the narrative’s pacing felt off; it rushed through moments that could have been rich explorations of self-acceptance and genuine connection. Instead, they often devolved into awkward dialogue or jarring comments that seemed out of touch with real preteen vernacular.
A notable instance was when Melody commented on her counselor’s box braids, asking if they were messy, reinforcing another stereotype that misses the mark entirely. As someone familiar with the nuances of hair care in the Black community, this moment felt particularly tone-deaf.
Personal Reflection
As I immersed myself in this story, I found myself wishing for a more nuanced and authentic representation, not just for Melody but for the community she represents. My heart sank with every ableist remark and clumsy portrayal; it felt like a missed opportunity to uplift the voices of kids with disabilities. If I had read this as a kid, I’d likely be left with so many mixed signals about my own worth and identity.
Conclusion
While I genuinely believe that Out of My Heart could resonate with some younger readers, particularly those looking for representations of camp experiences, I would caution anyone in the disability community to approach it critically. The book, unfortunately, does more to reinforce harmful stereotypes than to provide an empowering narrative.
In a world where literature can serve as a powerful tool for change and understanding, I find myself longing for stories that celebrate disability without infantilizing it, stories that inspire rather than pity. If you’re seeking a more uplifting alternative that authentically reflects diverse experiences and voices, I recommend looking elsewhere.
Overall, Out of My Heart is a reminder of how essential it is for authors to engage meaningfully with the identities they seek to portray. Here’s hoping for better narratives in the future!
Discover more about Out of My Heart (Out of My Mind #2) on GoodReads >>