A Heartfelt Dive into The Same Bright Stars by Ethan Joella
There are moments in reading when you stumble upon a story that feels like a gentle embrace, whispering truths about life, relationships, and the choices that shape us. Ethan Joella’s latest novel, The Same Bright Stars, enveloped me in just that kind of warmth and introspection—a book that isn’t simply read, but truly experienced. Having read Joella’s earlier work, A Quiet Life, I was eager to dive back into his world, and this time, he did not disappoint.
At the heart of this character-driven literary fiction is Jack Schmidt, a fifty-two-year-old man grappling with the weight of a life spent nurturing a family restaurant that has consumed him. Jack’s journey strikes a familiar chord, inviting us to ponder the sacrifices we make in the name of duty and the echoes of our decisions. His character is beautifully layered—flawed, yet deserving of empathy. Joella constructs Jack with such care that his internal conflicts resonate deeply. As I witnessed his struggles with business pressures and the looming DelDine takeover, I often found myself reflecting on my own life choices.
Joella’s writing style is another highlight. He masterfully employs a third-person perspective that allows us to delve into Jack’s psyche while revealing the complexities of those around him. It’s impressive how, even through Jack’s filtered view, the emotional richness of the supporting characters shines through. Each character—whether a dependable employee or a fleeting acquaintance—contributes layers to the narrative, showing a tapestry of relationships that can be messy, beautiful, and profoundly human.
What intrigued me most were the dual timelines, which elegantly intertwine past and present, illuminating how Jack’s history informs his current dilemmas. While I typically favor past narratives, here, I found the contemporary timeline to offer a strikingly relevant pulse to the story. It’s a reflection of how the past can shape our identities and relationships in ways we often overlook.
Set against the picturesque backdrop of Rehoboth Beach, Joella’s detailed descriptions make the setting come alive. I loved the interludes from “Rehoboth Beach: A Guidebook,” which were not just charming but enriched my understanding of the community that Jack holds dear. Joella’s connection to the area is palpable and adds authenticity to the narrative—a testament to how place can shape our lives.
While the pacing is slower, it perfectly matches the contemplative tone of the novel. And don’t be misled by the cover—it may suggest a breezy beach read, but The Same Bright Stars dives deeper into the melancholic complexities of life. It acknowledges dark themes without wallowing in sentimentality, making it a thought-provoking journey rather than mere escapism.
Reflecting on my reading experience, I realized how rare it is to find male protagonists who navigate emotional landscapes with such depth, and Joella’s skill in portraying these nuances left a lasting impression on me. The ending, unsweetened by forced resolutions, left me feeling hopeful without disillusionment—a true mark of Joella’s storytelling prowess.
This novel is a heartfelt invitation for literary fiction fans and those who appreciate character-driven narratives within tightly woven small-town settings. If you’re in search of a book that beautifully observes human strengths and vulnerabilities, The Same Bright Stars is perfect for you. I found immense value in its pages, and I suspect you will too.
4.25 stars.
Thank you, Scribner, for the DRC of The Same Bright Stars. This review reflects my honest opinion and the fulfillment I found within its pages.
Connect with me through my blog, The StoryGraph, Instagram, X/Twitter, and Facebook!