When Dimple Met Rishi: A Journey Through Young Love and Turbulent Tropes
Oh my GOD, you guys! I picked up When Dimple Met Rishi by Sandhya Menon despite hearing mixed reviews—some friends loved it, while others didn’t hold back their disdain. But let me tell you, this book ended up being an unforgettable rollercoaster of feelings and frustrations! It’s fascinating when a book elicits such polar opposite reactions. Can a story be both bad and transcendent in its own way? Buckle up as we dive into this quirky tale of young love and cultural complexity.
At its core, When Dimple Met Rishi attempts to flip traditional gender roles. Dimple Shah is ambitious and tech-savvy, yearning to ace her coding at a summer camp, while Rishi Patel embodies the romantic archetype, chasing after his dreams of love and partnership. This setup promises a refreshing perspective…until it doesn’t. Dimple’s continual assertion of her unique identity unintentionally paints an uncomfortable picture of “not like other girls” while exuding a sort of girl hate I wish we could see less of in literature.
Dimple’s dismissive attitude toward more traditionally feminine characters—like her portrayal of Isabelle—is frustrating. “Her booty shorts also barely covered her booty,” the text remarks, invoking eye rolls rather than sympathy. It makes me wonder: is this the message we want to send to young readers? Why must female characters compete by degrading each other? I wanted to love Dimple’s character, but her relentless need to place herself above other girls feels stale and hurtful.
And Rishi? Oh boy. While his infatuation with Dimple revealed a softer side, at times he bled into the borderline creepy. His adoration for her can easily slide into obsession, causing a weariness when facing scenes of Dimple hitting him and him just absorbing it all. It’s hard not to cringe when reading their relationship dynamic—taking invasion of privacy and emotional manipulation to a cringe-worthy level.
Yet, despite these glaring issues, I couldn’t help but appreciate Menon’s authentic attempt to address themes of identity and societal expectations for Indian-American girls. Dimple pushes back against these stereotypes, but the responses she receives from Rishi—who finds her frustrations amusing—highlight a disconnect in their emotional maturity. It’s a pity, as there were moments where Rishi could have stepped up and shown a more supportive side instead of providing helpless chuckles, which ultimately falls flat.
Writing style-wise, Menon has a light and whimsical touch that effectively captures the teen voice—paging through these bright, youthful interactions made me smile even as I shook my head at some of the content. However, the pacing hangs in a weird limbo where the story feels both rushed and drawn out, particularly in the romantic tensions that fizzled instead of igniting.
In conclusion, When Dimple Met Rishi might appeal to readers looking for a light-hearted young adult romance with cultural insights. If you can look past the frustrating “girl hate” elements, the awkward relationship dynamics, and the questionable narrative techniques, you might just find yourself charmed by its whimsical examination of young ambition and love. For me? It was a mix of cringing and chuckling, offering lessons in both representation and the importance of portraying women positively in literature. So grab a copy if you’re in for a wild ride, but prepare for some eye rolls along the way!
Discover more about When Dimple Met Rishi (Dimple and Rishi, #1) on GoodReads >>