Review: Where She Went (If I Stay, #2) by Gayle Forman
Sometimes, life nudges us toward exactly what we need, even when we’re not sure what that is. I picked up Where She Went, the highly anticipated sequel to If I Stay, based on a serendipitous recommendation from a random lady who probably sensed my need for a cathartic read during a long weekend. I was well acquainted with the first book’s emotional rollercoaster, but this time, there was something about the way Gayle Forman wrote Adam’s perspective that drew me in deeper.
Set three years after Mia’s life-changing decisions, the book takes us on a poignant journey through Adam’s grief and sense of alienation following their breakup. Already, the sense of impending doom forms a solid anchor in the narrative—his feelings are raw, even as he wrestles with the allure of moving on. Forman smartly brings forth the themes of loss, closure, and the haunting nature of ‘what-could-have-been’. It’s visceral, and I couldn’t help but draw parallels to my own experiences with heartbreak and longing.
One of the standout qualities of Where She Went is the narrative style. Shifted to Adam’s first-person point of view, the writing truly resonated with me. It felt mature and reflective; the three-year gap seemed to afford both the characters and the author room for growth. I found myself immersed in Adam’s emotional landscape as he navigates a world devoid of Mia, echoing that quote by Jon Basoff that I’ve often thought of: “There is no free will. Choices aren’t made.” Adam’s struggle to break free from the chains of his decisions is palpable and relatable.
Throughout the book, Forman’s exploration of music as a healing force stood out to me. Adam and Mia’s shared musical bond serves not only as a means of connection but also as a reflection of their unresolved feelings. As I read, I couldn’t help but think of a poignant lyric from Passenger: “You only know you love her when you let her go.” It encapsulates the essence of Adam’s journey—a deep longing intertwined with the acceptance of their diverging paths.
Moreover, as I delved deeper, I was left pondering the concept of closure. Forman masterfully illustrates that closure isn’t simply letting go; it’s the bittersweet acknowledgement of time, memories, and experiences that shape us. The quote, “It’s more like that melancholy feeling you get at the end of a really good vacation,” struck me. It’s a gentle reminder that while things may end, they also offer us the gift of growth and new beginnings.
In conclusion, Where She Went is not merely a sequel; it’s a transformative experience for anyone who has ever grappled with loss, healing, or unfulfilled promises. It poignantly captures the harsh realities of love, illustrating that sometimes life doesn’t come with clear resolutions. I believe this book will resonate deeply with young adults and those who appreciate emotional narratives steeped in music and introspection.
This reading experience has left me with a mix of nostalgia and hope—a reminder that embracing life’s complexities often invites us to reflect on our own journeys. Thank you, serendipitous lady, for guiding me to this book; it was just the cathartic read I didn’t know I needed.
Discover more about Where She Went (If I Stay, #2) on GoodReads >>