Review of You’d Be Home Now by Erin McNicol
The moment I picked up You’d Be Home Now, I was drawn in by the premise. There’s something about a story tackling heavy themes like loss and addiction that sparks my curiosity. Erin McNicol’s latest novel promised both introspection and a critical look at social issues, but as I delved deeper, I found myself yearning for the resonance that often accompanies tales of tragedy.
At its heart, this book surrounds Emory, a teenager grappling with life in a small town fractured by the opioid crisis—a tragic backdrop that begs exploration. Yet, despite its weighty themes, the narrative often felt more like “Nobel Prize Literature Bait” than a truly engaging read. McNicol lays down the hallmarks of a prestige piece: tragic events, absentee parents, and a heavy dose of melodrama without much substance. I can’t help but wonder—what unique angle does Emory’s story offer that warrants attention?
The characters seemed stuck in a repetitive loop of guilt and isolation. Emory, Joey, and Gage traversed a maze of emotional turmoil, but I found myself desiring more from their journeys. The relationship dynamics felt predictable and, frankly, constrictive. With over half the narrative revolving around Emory’s guilt and stagnant choices, I kept hoping for a shift—a plot twist, an action-packed moment, anything to ratchet up the tension!
While there were moments where McNicol successfully humanized the struggles surrounding addiction, such as the portrayal of the homeless and addicted, much of the deeper discussion around the opioid crisis felt heavy-handed. I was left wanting more nuance. Yes, doctors overprescribing is part of the dilemma, but there’s a myriad of complexities that could have added depth to this narrative. An examination of systemic healthcare failures and a proactive look at preventing addiction could have enriched the conversation—offering teens a chance to engage with these issues on a more meaningful level.
One character that particularly stood out was Liza, the embodiment of a certain kind of activism that, frankly, rubbed me the wrong way. While I appreciate the enthusiasm of young activists, Liza came off as an insufferable archetype. Her well-meaning but misguided attempts at activism felt more performative than effective, leaving me questioning the book’s stance on genuine advocacy. Teenagers are often painted as idealists, but McNicol’s narrative didn’t empower the nuanced discussions that young minds crave.
Though I began the book with a glimmer of hope, the pacing felt uneven. The last quarter precipitated a sudden rush of events, turning from a contemporary drama to episodes of forced excitement. The resolution felt unearned, shoving in “girl power” moments without giving space for the characters to navigate their emotions authentically.
In retrospect, You’d Be Home Now left me feeling a mix of disappointment and empathy. It tackles essential issues, but in doing so, it leans heavily into clichés and lacks the depth I yearned for. Perhaps it will resonate with teens navigating their own complicated worlds, but for readers seeking a profound exploration of trauma and recovery, this book might fall short.
If you enjoy YA novels that try to tackle significant issues but prefer a more dynamic execution, perhaps you’ll find a spark within its pages. However, if you’re looking for something that pushes boundaries and instills lasting emotional connections, you might want to seek elsewhere. Happy reading, and may your next find be one that provokes thought and inspires!
Discover more about You’d Be Home Now on GoodReads >>